Welcome to Totonno's
Totonno's, nestled in Coney Island, Brooklyn, is a legendary pizza joint celebrated for its authentic New York-style pies. Originally founded decades ago, this family-run establishment has become a cherished destination for both locals and visitors. Patrons rave about the rich, flavorful pizza sauce and the irresistible white pizza, often claiming it among the best in America. The casual atmosphere, complete with outdoor seating, makes it an inviting spot for families and groups. Despite its historic roots facing challenges, the dedication to quality remains steadfast. Enjoying a slice here is not just a meal; it’s a delicious experience steeped in tradition.
Totonno's: Reviews & Ratings
We used to eat at the 2nd Avenue location back in the day, this was our first visit to the Coney Island location. Ill put this pizza up against the best, I could drink the pizza sauce by the gallon its that delicious. We have our go to spot back for Pizza again.
Sadly the original pizza folks have passed on. They are arguably the originators of NY Pizza. The family is having trouble keeping it going and is only open on weekends. Its for sale and a great historic investment for someone! If I was only younger!
Youve likely read that Totonnos has some of the best pizza in America. What you read is true. In fact, everything youve read, from how amazing the white pizza is to how busy it is to how surly the owner lady is every bit of it is true. ...
Great place!! Pizza is incredible and the taste is really worth the wait. Yes!! There is at least an hour wait outside if you are lucky could be less and an hour wait inside if you are lucky and they dont have lots of orders to go you ...
Amazing Food grew up going to this place it has the best pizza that I have ever had in my life as my grandfather brought me here growing up. People can say whatever they about service this place is worth the wait. Ive seen changes ...
My all time favorite NYC pizza, hands down. No contest. Everyone else go home. Bring a friend and your appitite because this is a full pie joint. The service ...
Death, Taxes and Totonnos is the best pizza in NYC. These are three self evident truths I know are indisputable and irrefutable. I do not say this in a vacuum, this is not some cheap hyperbole. Ive eaten at the great pizza shops in the ...
Widely regarded as the best pizza place in America, and with good reason. I had a holiday to New York and Totonnos was top of my must eat list, it does not disappoint with a pizza that is beautifully light and crisp with tomato rich ...
Location
-
1524 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224 Hotline: (718) 372-8606
Welcome to Totonno's: A True Brooklyn Pizza Gem
Nestled in the vibrant neighborhood of Coney Island, Totonno's stands as a testament to the rich heritage of New York-style pizza. Since its inception, this family-run establishment has captured the hearts—and stomachs—of locals and visitors alike. With its motto of serving classic pizza, Totonno's aims to deliver an unfiltered taste of Brooklyn that resonates with tradition.
Why Totonno's is a Must-Visit
- Authentic New York Pizza: Totonno's is often hailed as one of the originators of NYC pizza. Many patrons claim its sauce is so delectable that you could drink it by the gallon!
- Diverse Menu: The pizza selection includes a classic cheese pie priced at $23. Customize your pizza with a variety of toppings ranging from savory sausage, mushrooms, and pepperoni to vegetarian options like peppers and onions—all available for an additional $2.50 each.
- Convenient Amenities: Whether you want to dine in with family, take out, or even enjoy a delivery, Totonno's has got you covered. The spacious outdoor seating is perfect for casual gatherings, and they are dog-friendly, making it a truly inclusive setting.
- Happy Hour Specials: Perfect for a casual hangout with friends or family, the happy hour specials will elevate your dining experience.
- Historic Charm: While the original family has passed on, their legacy lives on. Patrons like Joseph Weiss reflect on the nostalgic value of this beloved pizza hub, making it a historic investment for those who cherish Brooklyn's culinary past.
Customer Favorites and Highlights
The essence of Totonno's lies not only in its pizza but also in the shared experience it offers. Customer reviews echo the sentiment of waiting for a table is well worth the reward. With at least an hour wait being common, seasoned fans like Luay Alyass emphasize that the incredible taste makes every moment spent in line worthwhile.
Scott Kleinberg's review confirms that much of the buzz surrounding Totonno's is true—with both rave reviews for their exquisite white pizza and an acknowledgment of the surly but charming service from the owner. It's this blend of history, culinary expertise, and genuine Brooklyn charm that invites food lovers from far and wide.
Whether revisiting childhood memories or discovering a new favorite, Totonno's is more than just a place to eat; it's a place where stories are woven into the very dough of their pizza, inviting you to be a part of its ongoing legacy. Come for the amazing flavors; stay for the experience—dine at Totonno’s and savor all that this beloved establishment has to offer.
Location: 1524 Neptune Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11224
Phone: (718) 372-8606
